In praise of rewriting

Published

There is value in doing old things from scratch in a new project. You learn to simplify and to correct mistakes. If you reflect well on your previous design you may achieve a sort of reverse second system effect: a more spot-on, more straight-forward replacement for what was overly complicated. The common wisdom says you shouldn't rewrite a large existing codebase from scratch and it's probably correct for the vast majority of cases. However, if you are starting a new project that has overlap with what you've done before it may be an opportunity to get right what you didn't. If your new project has a sufficiently small scale that you are not forced into reusing bits from its predecessors rewriting should be fair game.

(read more)